• Hopeful
    Also, keep in mind that it is possible for narcissists to travel in groups, once again I hate to point out that Hitler and the Nazi party were extreme malignant narcissists, so yes you can have a massive amount of people that are narcissistic, it is not impossible. Erich Fromm first mention group narcissism. I agree that you cannot generalize, it takes a very well trained, and I mean on the profiler level do identify a real malignant narcissist. Some people term it as the inability to form long lasting relationships, this is not so, Hitler had a long term relationship with Eva, was a real part of the Nazi regime.

    The really sad part is that you have junior psychologists and wanna-be psychologists, who have had no life experience with true narcissists - trying to diagnose people who may not really be a narcissist at all. I believe the experts when they say, a true malignant narcissist cannot be captured.
  • Hopeful
    Narcissists are extremely hard to read, the depth of the insanity is only apparent to those closest to them, it is not apparent to just anyone, a malignant narcissist isn't detectable sometimes even by the most trained of psychologists, you have to be very close to them. Simple charm and grandiose ideas doesn't describe the degree to which these folks cross over the line into real insanity. There is a neuron in the brain somewhere that can tell us why these folks don't function right, I would just like to know why they haven't located that neuron just yet, I mean look how long ago Hitler happened.
  • cindyplatt
    As an educator and a mother I felt this information gave me a few aha moments. I appreciate in the e-book the preface: "draw you own conclusions" based on your experiences and what you have observed. I feel keeping it all in perspective there is an awareness that can be gained.
  • writerdad
    Seems to me that there are seeds for some good conversation, debate and dialogue here.

    But we need more people in the garden.


  • You can never have too many people in the garden, unless of course they are standing on your rose bushes. I hate when that happens.
  • writerdad
    You can have too few people in the garden, though! That's when stuff just withers and dies. :(
  • WelshScribe
    Ahh but Sean, us narcissists must be ignored. Can't feed us what we want ;)
  • menwithpens
    More of this bothers me, and I really feel quite strongly about this, so I'm going to write my thoughts out. I think I may have scared away the authors, but I really believe that this merits some calm discussion and polite debate. Anyways, onwards.

    There are not only the authors that who were purportedly involved with narcissists but some personal stories of other people within the ebook as well. While I don't discredit anyone's personal experience, because that is their perceptions of events and thus valid, the math and statistics just aren't supporting this enough for me to feel comfortable.

    It's nearly impossible that so many people (I'm assuming throughout the United States) not only had relationships with narcissists, but furthermore managed to meet each other coincidentally. Could it happen? Sure – but the odds are severely against it. There are a lot of people in the States, and again, only about 1% have a true narcissist disorder.

    Also a question I have – were any of the purported narcissists medically diagnosed with the disorder? Again, maybe they were, and that's fine, but I'm really incredulous at how many people suddenly seem to be coming out.

    It's really important, when exploring psychological issues, to remember that there's a huge difference between an actual medical issue and just someone who behaves badly. Plenty of people walk around saying, "Oh, I have ADD," or, "I must have Alzheimer's," but that doesn't make it a reality. We all have forgetful moments or times where we can't follow a list or periods where we show some ego, but that doesn't point to psychological issues. Nor does getting on the bandwagon and bringing everyone along help.

    Educate, yes, but where in the ebook does it say, "This is really not a common disorder," or, "Most people are not narcissists." It doesn't. This concerns me. By reading something generalized, implicative and assumptive, we can all point to people in our lives and suddenly label them with a diagnosis to explain their behaviour (or even worse, our own behaviour!) – when we are in no way qualified to do so.

    I'm also wondering what the ultimate goal of giving away this free ebook might be. Is there some kind of service coming afterwards and it's a lead-in? Is it just a nice (albeit harmful, I feel) gesture for the world? Very rarely do people invest their time and money to give something away for free and without some other plan in behind it. What's the motive?

    I'll go lay off the coffee now and stop rambling on – clearly I've had more than my fair share!
  • I like to read dialogue between folk I respect. To add another perspective here, I'd just like to say I haven't read the ebook because I've already read Lori's posts about Dark Hearts, as she called them. I enjoyed them; they made me think about and examine behavioural patterns - not just occasional behaviours - in myself and others. I also enjoyed Marc's black belt insights and gentle wisdom in his Daily Aikido blog. What both of these black belt friends of mine have in common is a desire to pass on aspects of the aware, alert, wise and intuitive mindsets that keep us out of danger in the first place, or calm enough to cope and survive if we're faced with threatening people and situations. Reading these comments today made me smile; I'm proud to have friends who care enough about the welfare of strangers to want to make a difference, and who are brave enough to speak up for what they believe in.
  • Hi Sean,

    Thank you for letting Betsy and I guest post here today! We've been getting great feedback about how empowering the ebook is and that the focus on personal responsibility for the relationship in chapter six is very helpful.

    Just to clarify, I did want to add this from the Mayo Clinic:

    "Narcissistic personality disorder is a mental disorder in which people have an inflated sense of their own importance and a deep need for admiration. Those with narcissistic personality disorder believe that they're superior to others and have little regard for other people's feelings. But behind this mask of ultra-confidence lies a fragile self-esteem, vulnerable to the slightest criticism.

    "Narcissistic personality disorder is one of several types of personality disorders. Personality disorders are conditions in which people have traits that cause them to feel and behave in socially distressing ways, limiting their ability to function in relationships and in other areas of their life, such as work or school."

  • WelshScribe
    Another generalisation Lori.

    What about the statistic that Narcissistic Personality Disorder only affects around 1% of the general population?

    Yet, according to your book, I am a narcissist because I have done *everything* you said a narcissist does in an argument with friends, family and even my fiancée.

    However, my friends, family and even my fiancée has done the *exact* same thing to me.

    For every person that you are helping, that you are empowering, how many are you harming? How many of those are false positives?
  • menwithpens
    Having some background in psychology studies, I have to agree with Welshscribe. I read the ebook after it was pointed out to me by a friend, and I found it very generalized and dangerous. Like Welshscribe mentioned, everyone I know, including myself, can easily be labeled incorrectly.

    The prevalence of narcissism as a disorder in the general population is about 1%. Maaaaybe slightly more. But according to this ebook, almost anyone – parents, teachers, police officers – are raving narcissists. I disagree highly with that implication, and I'm quite concerned that many people are going to read this and run around labeling the people they have conflict with as narcissists, when in actual fact, it's just two people not getting along.

    There's another key: two people. It always takes two to tango, and pointing to the other party as being to blame is an irresponsible mindset. Yes, there are some cases where it really is the other person's fault, but in most cases, fault lies on both sides. And, the one pointing out at someone else as being the problem is very often the one with the most blame to shoulder, in my opinion.

    I would have much rather read an ebook that dealt with taking ownership for our responsibilities in relationships that didn't work out or that resulted in conflict. The attitude of, "It's not me, it's him!" or, "It's not my fault," is a true ostrich mindset. Head in the sand.

    But, people don't like to work at themselves and look in the mirror, so sadly they look for reasons and excuses "this" happened to them. And that's why I find this ebook dangerous - because many readers are going to leap up and say, "That's it!!! This is why my marriage/coworker/boss relationship isn't working!!! A NARCISSIST!!!"

    Prevalence: 1% of the population. Try again.
  • WelshScribe
    Is it just me or can anyone else see the inherent danger in these kinds of books?

    I'm sorry Lori, I really am, but neither you or Betsy have the qualifications necessary to write a book on this matter. As commendable as it is to want to help "just one person", there is little to no consideration given to the amount of psychological damage you may cause others.

    I downloaded the book yesterday, read through it and even with my very limited knowledge of psychology I can see that you've taken sound psychological concepts and twisted them to fit into the book.

    Take Narcisstic Personality Disorder itself; it "affects between 0.7 and 1 percent of the general population" - http://www.psychiatric-disorders.com/articles/personality-disorders/narcissistic-disorder.php

    And yet the generalisations you make in the book means that everyone, myself included, can be labelled as a narcissist.

    As such, I fear some will take your book, misdiagnose their situation and end up wielding it like a child that has found his dad's shotgun.
  • Good morning Sean, Cindy and Lori !

    Sean, thank you so much for the forum to get this message out. It's early here in Minnesota so I may have missed the download link embedded in the post. Here's one: http://bit.ly/bZRQQZ and of course should readers visit Think Like A Black Belt or PassingThru, they'll find it, too.

    We've realized there is much more to write on this subject, and part of that is gathering stories and anecdotes as examples. We're hoping folks who have a story they're willing to share would do so either in the comments or send it to us by email. Many more people than we realize may feel trapped in a hopeless relationship with a narcissist. We must be vigilant about providing the necessary skills for our children to neutralize and discourage an overture that could lead to victimization. Thanks so much for your support, Sean and Cindy.
blog comments powered by Disqus