• Not Hurley
    Yeah, that science thing. Four people are in a submarine; FOUR BLOCKS of C4 explode - and the people swim out. Not only scientifically unbelievable, but extremely horrible writing. The show is filled with crap like this and it is amazing how many people eat it up thinking it to be intelligent.

    It isn't.
  • Diana Sholl
    Not Hurley, no it is you who are not intelligent as that is the point, 4 people and 4 sticks, that is how the entire parallels work. You just do not have a creative brain that thinks in a certain way and I feel very sorry for you but nothing any of us can do. You miss out on an awesome show and just look stupid writing a comment that is the point not the criticism.
  • dianasholl
    Brilliant. Could not have put it better myself. An excellent summary of the greatest series ever to be written. I love it and will weep buckets when it ends.
  • writerdad
    I will cry and cry and cry and cry and then I'll cry some more.

    Not really, but kinda sorta inside. :)
  • Adam G.
    Wow, I am so glad I just read this. " I feel fortunate that I’ve been able to see the story unfold as I have." That is exactly how I have been feeling since the start of this season. I feel so fortunate to be lucky enough to have been watching it since the end of the 1st season. I own all the DVD's and it's great watching them. But it is a totally different experience watching it episode by episode on tv.

    Just think about the first season. Theories and speculation back then were NOWHERE NEAR what the show became. Watching it on DVD I feel as if you miss this total view of the show that can only be attained for those of us that have gotten to watch it most or all of the way through on TV. I feel so lucky to be able to be a part of this amazing weekly mindtrip.

    I didn't get to see the Grateful Dead in the 70's, and many other things, but one of my favorite things to be a part of this past decade is Lost, without a doubt. I don't care what anybody might say about this, but I will boldly state that Lost is the best television show I have ever watched. I've lived in this house since last June, and I didn't physically hook my cable up to the tv until Feb 2(the day of the season premiere). I only hope I will be able to find a show I can enjoy half as much as I have loved being a part of this crazy ride for the past 6 years.
  • dianasholl
    I could not agree more Adam and I watched the series through from Series 1 again during recent mobility problems. It was mind boggling the way I could see the patterns and clues in every episode. A masterpiece of skilful writing and the acting is first rate too. I agree with Adam, nothing gets better than LOST.
  • Bubba
    I can't it's the best show ever just because I find it hard to define anything that way. BUT, I have absolutely loved Lost. I find it hard to think of another show I've savored like I have this final season. It's moving incredibly fast but doesn't feel rushed like some shows (BSG hint, hint). I have to say TV has some incredible shows these days. The Shield was excellent, Sopranos, Damages, Rescue Me... but Lost is so different. Fantasy without being silly, sci-fi without the lasers, the cultural references, the amazing story arcs. I can go on and on. The acting is good but not great. The writing is really the star.

    I regret reading an article giving away the time-travel aspect. I read it, I think, after season 3. I knew right away they had it right. I maybe could have figured it out, and I though about it at one point, but after reading it i knew for sure. Still, it's been an incredible ride.
  • dianasholl
    Acting not great? Are you blind? It is amazing, the guy who plays Ben for instance, every single movement of the guy's body has a story to tell. I would say it is your interpretation skills that are rather limited. The acting in this even beats the UK shows which is unusual.
  • dianasholl
    I think LOST is the best too and I cannot stop thinking about it. I am going to be so gutted when it ends and, at the same time, I cannot wait to know the end. Mostly I want all the characters to be there again and none of them to be bad or dead. I love Richard Alpert and I love Jack etc. and Jacob is awesome. If I had thought up this series I would wear a t-shirt saying how brilliant I am. It is sensational and what I love most is how it makes my mind keeping working long after an episode finishes, piecing all the narratives together and the characters.
  • ClarenceG
    Great blog. But I must disagree (sort of) with one thing you said. Lost is not the best show on network TV, it is the best show on ALL of TV. Cable included, regardless of how many boundaries they can cross.

    I watch almost nothing on network TV because of the superior quality of cable programming, but Lost is still the best, so that says a lot about Lost.

    No show before or after will even come close to Lost.
  • Hi there, Clarence!

    Yeah, as far as ambition. I'd have to agree. LOST is the best show ever. I can't wait for it to start again! Counting the days in fact. : )

    Thanks for dropping by!
  • Yes, our family, too, is a big fan of Lost.

    I've also wondered about the writing of TV shows. I guess they must lay out everything at the beginning of the show so they can wrap it up in the end.

    Monk is another example. They finally brought it to an end. I assume they must have planned how she (Trudy) was killed from the very beginning and then intertwined little hints here and there throughout the entire run of it. Good show but not as much in-depth or twist or turns as in Lost
  • Malin
    I watched the first season and loved it. Got through about half of the episodes of the next season and then refused to watch any more. It just didn't go anywhere, I felt like they were repeating the same kind of events just for effect and there wasn't any point to the events anymore. (Am I making myself clear? This is my second language and I'm not sure about the words here. I'm sorry if I'm making a confused impression!) I felt the same about Prison Break I might add.

    Great blog btw, found you through Zen Habits and your recent guest post :)
  • Brandie
    I whole-heartedly agree with your spiel here....I had been a huge fan of Lost, until the writer's strike. Since then I have gotten behind and need to brush up on what I have missed.
    Another show I feel had and perhaps still does have some excellent potential was/is HEROES.
  • Clarkson: IF the writers have no clue what's up season to season, then they are that much more amazing for creating a show so unbelievably well threaded after five years. That alone would add an exponent to my awe.
  • Clarkson
    A show that's made up as it goes. Even the writers have no clue season to season. Totally weak.
  • Diana Sholl
    Clarkson, LOST a weak show? No, your brain is just not up to following the patterns and parallel scenes. It is amazing and highly intelligent. Stick to cartoons, you will follow them.
  • Rachel: Hi, Rachel. My pleasure, I'm thrilled to meet you!
  • I LOVE this post and LOST. Thanks for the BLOG comment the other day and for subscribing! I look forward to your future posts.
  • Mare: That's how it is for me, and one of the reasons I so love watching LOST. While watching, I imagine all the story threads and all the places it could take my own writing.

    People in the Sun: That's really cool! I never played any of the online stuff, but I AM one of the seven people who read that spin off book that came out a few years ago (I think in between the second and third seasons) Not very good, but hey, it was LOST.

    Yolanda: I hear ya, Yolanda, but I swear, it has little to do with the Island. It's not about the rescue, it's about the connection, mystery, and intrigue.

    Miko's Girl: It's just that there's nothing there. Honestly, the local dive market that buys their produce from local farmers has WAY better produce than the "Farmer's Market" that's just a few blocks away, and at a fraction of the price.
  • I've tried once or twice to watch Lost...I think it is outside my bandwidth. I'm more of a Dancing with the Stars, Grey's Anatomy, Desperate Housewives, Brothers and Sisters kind of girl.

    BTW, thx for stopping by my blog -- why so disappointed in the CSA in your area?
  • ...I'll admit. I was sucked into LOST for the first couple of seasons. I even went as far as watching them back to back at period where I took a month away from writing. However, right before they were about to be rescued...for the millionth time...I soon gave up.

    I think I'm an instant gratification type gal. I get really antsy and I want it all now. This was no different w/ LOST. I just couldn't sit through the prolonged agony and so I eventually fell off the LOST bandwagon.

    However, I see I probably didn't miss much as the latest episode preview I glanced at showed Jack right back on the island.

    ....I digress...
  • Actually, Lost made me start blogging. It involves one thing you don't mention: that game they had between seasons, where you had to find clues on various fake sites and various fake profiles on real sites, like Flickr. I wanted to write a book and give the invented characters fake web presence, but I didn't know anything about blogging, so I started a blog. Never did the fake thing, though.
  • Hi Sean: I've never watched an episode of Lost, but this reminded me of something I read recently from Margaret Atwood. A few times she's devoted months to writing a novel, only to realize that it wasn't really going anywhere. Each of these times the novel has reappeared as a chapter in another book, or even as a sentence :-)
  • Elle: I haven't seen Breaking Bad, but I'm always on the lookout for something new and cool. There's only one LOST, but plenty of room for more that's awesome. Thanks for the recommendation. I'll check it out.

    Steve: "Most certainly a ground breaking show, and one that media students will be picking apart for quite some time." I fully agree with that. I think that for the most part, people don't quite realize how groundbreaking this show is. History will be kind. Twin Peaks and Moonlighting were both awesome, but (especially Twin Peaks) ended up not blossoming to full fruition. I don't see that happening with LOST. I feel like we're about to have a ful final season of WOW. You are right though, that the best shows of today are standing on the shoulders of the past. I can't wait to see what will be standing on LOST.

    Vered: I'm with you. TV can be totally soul sucking, but LOST isn't. We download it and watch it every Thursday, one day after it airs. It is yummy. Check out a few episodes (commercial free) on DVD and see if your mind is blown.

    Steely Dad: Nothing like Gilligan's Island. Them being stranded is like (maybe) 10% of the show. It probably has more in common with the History and Discovery shows you're watching now. I swear.
  • LOL! I can't believe you're a Lost fan. I have these really good friends who are hardcore Lost fans. I used to always call them in the middle of episodes just to mess with them.

    I must admit, I've never seen a single episode. It seems like a more advanced version of Gilligan's Island. Plus, I'm sure it's too high-brow for me. I can't dedicate more than 30 minutes of my dwindling attention span to a single activity. Thus, I watch shows like Seinfeld and The Office. I love Mary Tyler Moore reruns. Oh, I also watch History and Discovery shows. I guess I either love sitcoms or shows about Hitler.
  • I don't watch it, not because I don't like it, but simply because I don't watch TV. :)
  • Most certainly a ground breaking show, and one that media students will be picking apart for quite some time. I can't remember anything else that's packed in so many twists, turns and innovations while developing 'real' characters that you can invest in and cheer for.

    Sometimes I just wanna get a whiteboard on the wall while I'm watching so I can map it all out. How does he know that again? When did he tell her that? How did she get there?

    Best show ever? It's up there. But don't forget other ground breaking episodic TV that changes how shows are written. I'm thinking Moonlighting and Twin Peaks.
  • I totally agree. I heart Lost! Have you seen Breaking Bad. It's on AMC. It's nothing like Lost but still very good.
  • Friar: Alright, that totally works.

    GreenJello: I agree. We don't even have a TV, but we download LOST every week and watch with baited breath. It's a big boiling pot of cool beans.

    Tricia: It's only good if you like stuff that starts out awesome and is awesome the whole time and then never stops being awesome. : > )
  • I've never tuned in, but such a sincere recommendation has certainly piqued my curiosity. I'm always intrigued and Cherise-cat happy when I can fall in love with a show's writers.
  • Never watched an episode. But then again, I rarely (if ever) watch tv, so it's not surprising that I haven't seen it. Too many other things to do than to park my butt in front of the telly...
  • @Writer Dad

    How about this for a "HELL YEAH?"

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aSVfYwdGSsQ
  • Friar: Alright, now THAT sounds like some hellz yeah! I'll add another season to the queue.

    Jake: I have to wait until Thursday, but that it's always the carrot at the end of my Thursday for sure. If network TV has done drama better than that, I need to be reminded what it was.
  • You're absolutely right; this has to be the best drama in the history of TV. The best thing about it is that you are incapable of looking away as soon as it comes on each Wednesday night.
  • @Writerdad
    Some episodes are better than other. Basically, the best shows are when they smash or blow sh*t up.

    Like the one where they blew up a cement truck with 1000 lbs of explosives. Or they recreated a medieval weapon that fired 500 exploding rockets. One smashed a car into a snowplow at 70 mph and peeled it apart like a tin can.
  • Stacey: If you don't love the Muppet Show, you're dead inside for sure, but LOST is just unbelievable. I can't wait until 2010. That's why I'm starting at the beginning next week and watching the whole thing through with another set of eyes.

    James: Hi James, nice to know you! The Wire is another one of my favorites. Phenomenal across the board. For sheer writing, I might even have to slip the blue ribbon to the boys in Baltimore. But for action, intrigue and What Da WHAT!?! it's all about the LOST.

    Karen: Trust me on this Karen, you will LOVE it. Rent it from Netflix and hit Cindy and I with the emails when you're confused. It's the coolest mystery to unspool. Jason will love it as well. It's a big swinging sack of super cool. I promise.
  • Karen
    Wow, I would never have guessed. We don't have any TV, even snow, so I've never watched LOST. I think I watched the first episode when I was prego with Gus and that's when we gave our TV the boot. The only show I have to watch online is the Office, because it is SO funny. We did watch the Rome series and the Deadwood Series which we have on DVD and were really good.
  • I agree WriterDad. LOST is one of the best shows ever. Others are terrific for other reasons (The Wire comes to mind) but LOST is the one that take me to multiple places all at once. I can't wait til the final season and am glad I can watch it all from the beginning on disc. Good stuff.
  • I hear you Writer Dad, LOST is the BEST TV show EVER! J.D. mentioned some great shows (who doesn't love The Muppet Show), but LOST wins in my mind. Can you believe we have to wait until 2010 for the next episode? This gives me many months to play outside, but I'm looking forward to the next season.
  • J.D: Just start from the beginning, and be patient 2/3 through to the end of Season 3. You'll end the 5th with a holy wow.

    Henry: LOL! Cool beans.

    Friar: Alright Friar, help me out. I LOVED Myth Busters... on paper. Then I rented it from Netflix and was disappointed. Which episodes are good? I'd love to give it another shot.
  • I must be so lame. I have NEVER seen Lost.

    Or Twenty Four. Or Prison Break. Or the Amazing Race.

    Don't like the long-term commitment. You have to keep following the shows to keep track of them. You miss one key episode, and you're screwed.

    I'm more into one-night stands. Like South Park, or Mythbusters.
  • J. D., if you love those shows, then Lost is for you. It has elements of each!

    There are castaways like Gilligan's Island, fuzzy bears like The Muppet Show, women who are "enceinte" like I Love Lucy . . . as for The Brady Bunch, I believe the Dharma pantry stocks pork chops and apple sauce.
  • That's a pretty serious commitment.

    I mean, when you say best TV show ever ... are we including The Brady Bunch, Gilligan's Island, I Love Lucy, The Muppet Show, ... etc.?

    This sounds pretty serious. I might need to give LOST a shot.
  • Prairie Chick: I often prefer slower movies as well. I'll take character over car chases any day. I love the idea about living amid the quiet of the open prairie, though I admit I might not do it simply for the lack of a good television signal. I'll also admit that I have a hard time remembering the first I in prairie. : > )

    Mr. Nuggets: In a way, you win. I almost envy you being able to watch all 5 seasons at once on DVD. Back to back is best!

    Janice: Ah.. you'll gorge in another year then. I promise, even with all the hype surrounding it, LOST is yummy.
  • I haven't watched for two reasons. First, I initially avoid anything folk rave about because it can often lead to disappointment. I like to wait till shows settle down then get them on DVD and have three hour fests. Secondly, I'm obsessive. I suspected I'd get hooked, right from the first ads for it. I've already been hooked on 24 and The West Wing. And now Serial and Milk...
  • I now feel like I've missed the Apocalypse! Ok, Netflix here I come.

    Why have I missed it? I have an aversion to getting addicted to a television series 'cuz I know I'm going to have some ungodly project at work that will throw me off for three weeks and then I'll be totally .... cough.... lost.
  • You are preaching to the choir, man! I have a love-hate relationship with television. I love me a good show but my standards are hard to meet and we survive in the boondocks on two national channels that love to air trash (not their fault, a sad reflection of our sex/crime/star crazed society). They showed LOST the first four seasons and Prairie Guy and I were totally hooked. Only time you could get us glued to the TV and recording a show and watching it religiously. Then, imagine our HORROR when they stopped airing it season 5 and moved it to a cable channel. NOOOOOOO................... Fortunately we can watch it online and do, even if we don't have a laptop and thus are glued to the computer at the work centre in our Dining Room once a week. Best show ever made, forever and ever amen. You are right that it has the perfect combination of character development and action. I tend to love slower movies that develop character and emotion and I love action only if I love the people involved so it is PERFECT for me. I also love the spiritual undertones that wouldn't bother anyone not into that but totally tickles my fancy.
  • Hayden: Dudette, it is SO not to late. Netflix will save your soul.

    Trina: Clever enough to make me smile. : > )
  • Trina
    Yes, I watch L(ove the) O(ccular)S(izzle and)T(wists)!
  • When it first came out, it seemed to have a very "Lord of The Flies" thing going on. Since I hated LOTF, I was in no way motivated to watch the show. Then people were all over it in American Idol fandom style. Since I don't care for American Idol either, it didn't seem like a good sign. By the time I realized that it was probably a pretty decent story, I had already missed several seasons.
  • Harry: How wonderful to see you here! Yes, the plotlines make me drool as well. I started writing during the fourth season and I'd be a bald faced liar if I didn't admit that the show was hugely influential. Before I started Writer Dad, I wrote a 600 page novel. It was in no way a wannabe LOST, but the show cast a long shadow on the possibilities of writing without fear (or limits).

    Jeremy: I'd say, just wait. Things that have seemed unable to be explained by science, have ended up with an explanation in the end. Cuse and Lindelhoff had said from the beginning that the show is founded in science. It's one of the things I find most intriguing. Violently shaken, not stirred - I love it.

    SingleParentDad: Nextflix my man. Netflix. Buy/borrow/steal. Totally worth it.

    Mike: If you can ever sink back in, deep and on DVD, I highly recommend it. But it's hard to argue with the quiet of a campground. : > )

    Tara: We're starting over now. I've been eager to watch it from the beginning for a while. I can do a couple of episodes a week and be all caught up for season 6. It will be the most awesomest thing ever.

    Chase: Dude, it's really really awesome. I mean like really awesome. It doesn't have any of the sucky let down of the X-files. The mystery totally delivers and the writing's razor sharp. Some of the episodes are as good as great cinema. Seriously. It. IS. Awesome.

    Nicki: I skip those two! Why, why, WHY would a show as good as LOST reduce themselves to clip shows? Oh yeah, the networks.

    Marc: I do agree about the season 3 slump, but I would add that LOST at its worst is better than most shows at their best.

    Jen: Walkabout is a fantastic episode. It hasn't changed television for me, but is has certainly influenced my writing. Thanks for stopping by!

    Henry: I'll check it out! You're certainly right about it giving families lots to talk about.

    Lisis: Seriously, my wife LOVES the show. It's very spiritual, even amid all the mystery and action.

    Always Home and Uncool: LOL. : ? )

    Kim: I like watching them week to week, but I can't even imagine watching the awesome of 3-5 all in one fell swoop. It would be cooler than cool. It might not be the best show ever, but it is probably the best show yet for me.

    GinaBad: Thanks! Yeah, I LOVE the discussion the show invites, probably more than anything. I'm with you. My wife and I are planning to start over at season one next week and keep on going until January. Good times ahead indeed.
  • Very well written! I agree with everything here, especially what you've written about characterization. An intelligent show for intelligent people at last, one that makes you think and then rethink. It's taught me a lot, too, about my passion, writing fiction. I'm spending the rest of the year rewatching the the past seasons. Wonderful cast too, and if you start to dislike or lose interest in a character, usually you are pulled back in to him or her by plotline and more fine acting. (Not always, but nothing is perfect, and not everyone can be Michael Emerson.)
  • I watched the first two seasons and then got stuck at the beginning of Season 3. Then starting three weeks ago I watched seasons 3-5. I really enjoy the show and kind of wish I wasn't caught up so there was more to watch.

    I'm not going to watch it on television though - I'll probably ignore it next season and then watch all of the season at once.

    Is it the best show ever? I'm not sure but it's one of my favorites.
  • Sorry. I saw the graphic and thought this was gonna be about "Dharma & Greg."
  • You know, I've never watched it (seemed more like a "guy thing") but you've laid this out so eloquently and convincingly, I may have to give it a try. Thank goodness for Netflix and being able to watch entire seasons in a weekend. :)

    BTW, your tweet for this? Very persuasive. ;-)
  • I watch Lost with my children, which has led to some good observations about family relationships on the show. I wrote about that last week for Time Out, New York; it's reposted at my blog here:

    http://whendaddywasdaddy.wordpress.com/2009/05/16/lost-know-best
  • Jen
    I agree with you, wholeheartedly. I have loved LOST since the pilot, became hopelessly addicted after watching Walkabout and now worry about the empty spot I'll be left with after next season. LOST has changed television for me.

    Thanks to the Daily Blond for RT your post. :)
  • I've got the last 4 episodes of the season on my Sky+ box (TiVo) waiting to go (which is why I skimmed over Tara's comment - no offence Tara lol)

    There was a bit of a slump in season 3 (I think) when a whole load of my friends and family gave up on the show. Boy are they regretting that now :)

    Best ever? Probably but it doesn't occupy that top spot on its own. BSG was also frakking awesome ;) Fringe is quickly catching up.

    Sean, send that original email that you sent to Dave to Eric, show him what he's missing out on hehe
  • Do I watch LOST????? Ummmm, YES! Every. Single. Episode (with the exception of those annoying recaps). It rocks.
  • I like to read about the new television series ever year by checking with TV Guide. And I must admit that when I first heard about LOST, I was intrigued. It sounded like it would be a good premise for a show.

    For some reason, though, I never got to watch it. I decided not to add it to the list of shows I regularly watched and I was glad to as well. I started to hear plot points, and the series sounded absolutely ridiculous.

    Don't get me wrong, I am a fan of good stories and I enjoy science fiction but a story about a magical island that is fragmented by time jumps and has more than one crashed plane on it with monsters and mystery doesn't really make sense. I really don't think I want to watch something like that.

    The continued mystery plot reminds me of The X-files. I wasted five years watching that stupid show that never gave us any answers or made any sense whatsoever.

    That is why I don't watch or care to watch LOST!
  • Ooo now you're speaking my language Sean!
    I am totally with you on this one. It's the only show I MUST watch no matter what and it's the only show that has constantly kept my brain clicking throughout all seasons.
    I love that we don't know what the hell is going on. I hate that we don't know what the hell is going on!
    I think its fantastic that we really know all these characters and that the writers can't get away with sloppy scripts because fans know and understand each and every one of their motivations now.
    One of the best things for me has also been that no one is safe - characters have been 'lost' throughout the series and you are never entirely sure who is going to stay and who is going to go.
    I absolutely can't wait for the final season and, while I'll be sad to see it go, I'm really please that they will be ending it on a high (we hope!)
    Of course then it will be time to go right back to the begining and watch it all again knowing what we know. A bit like The Usual Suspects!
  • Do you watch LOST? -- No

    If not, what’s kept you away? -- A long time ago, in a state not so far away, I stopped watching episode TV shows when I worked back shift. It was too easy to start losing track of things especially since video recorders had just started hitting the market and were way too expensive for us.

    As time went on, I've found myself watching less and less TV. While I did watch the first two seasons of Lost, I eventually lost interest in Lost. The fact that it was shifted to late night in our area during basketball season didn't help.

    We've been traveling since May 1st and I've watched perhaps 45 minutes of TV -- and that was in the first campground.
  • I don't watch it, because it is on a subscription service, that I am currently refusing to pay for. It is definitely a series I would like to watch, and I aim to buy/borrow/steal the DVD box sets at some point.
  • Lost is the best TV show I've ever been sucked into. About #3, though, I'd say much of the things that involve Locke (especially this season) cannot be explained by science. Or anything that has to do with the magical Buddhist dharma wheel.

    But lost is a perfect cocktail of character development, mythology, and the Zeigarnik effect. Violently shaken, not stirred.
  • Lost is incredible on many levels. The writing is amazing, the twisted plotlines make me drool with envy, but it's the characters I love most. In one of the season premiers, the creators were talking about how Lost is all about the characters and that's something that us Pen Men have been telling people for years. Made my heart sing to hear that.
blog comments powered by Disqus